If you have uploaded a few videos and the comment section is empty, it is tempting to look at a shortcut. Searches for buy youtube comments are common for exactly that reason: an empty box under a video feels like a sign that nobody cares, and a busy one feels like proof that people do. This guide explains what actually happens when you pay for comments, what YouTube’s own rules say, where the real risks sit, and how to get genuine comments from real viewers instead.
We are a UK social media, SEO and web agency, based in Guildford and Portsmouth, and we help small businesses and creators with video every week. We will not tell you where to buy anything, because we do not think it is a good idea. What we can do is tell you plainly what you would be buying and what to do instead.
What happens when you buy youtube comments
Sellers usually offer a package: pay a set price and comments appear under your video within hours or days. They tend to fall into three types. The first is generic comments such as “great video” or “love this”, often posted from accounts with no history. The second is comments written from a list you supply or a seller’s script. The third is comments posted by real people paid a tiny amount per task, sometimes from other countries and with no interest in your topic.
All three share the same problem: none of those people watched your video because they wanted to. The comment is a decoration, not a conversation. Real comments ask questions, disagree, add a story, or mention a specific moment. Bought ones almost never do, and that difference is easy to spot for viewers and for YouTube’s systems.
There is also a practical issue. Comments from brand-new or empty accounts, posted in a burst, with similar wording, look exactly like spam. YouTube has comment filters designed to catch this kind of pattern, and creators can choose to hold comments for review. YouTube’s help page on holding comments explains that comments that may be spam, self-promotion or gibberish can be held and are not public unless approved. A comment you paid for can therefore disappear before anyone sees it.
What you get for your money
In plain terms, you get text under a video. You do not get an audience, watch time, subscribers or customers. The video’s performance still depends on whether people click it, stay watching and come back. A comment count with no matching views, likes or watch time looks odd, and that mismatch is one of the first things a careful viewer notices.
What YouTube’s rules say
This is the part that matters most. YouTube has a fake engagement policy. According to YouTube’s fake engagement policy, it does not allow anything that artificially increases the number of views, likes, comments or other metrics. The same page lists related behaviour that is also not allowed, including promoting services that inflate metrics and “sub4sub” arrangements where channels only subscribe to each other in return.
The page also describes what can happen. Content that breaks the policy is removed and you receive an email. For a first violation, YouTube says you will usually get a warning with no penalty to the channel. Repeating the same violation within the warning period can lead to a strike, and three strikes within 90 days can lead to the channel being terminated. Channels can also be terminated for repeated violations, for a single case of severe abuse, or if the channel exists mainly to break the rules. The policy also says that if you hire someone to promote your channel and they break the rules, that can lead to your channel being removed too.
We have summarised the policy as we read it on the day we wrote this. Policies change, so check the page itself before you decide anything.
Why a warning is not harmless
A first warning with no channel penalty sounds mild. But a warning is a record that your channel has been flagged. If you are a business building a video library, or a creator working toward monetisation, you do not want any history of rule-breaking attached to the channel you are trying to grow.
The real risks, beyond the rulebook
Even if you set YouTube’s policy aside, there are good commercial reasons not to buy youtube comments. Let us go through them one by one.
- Wasted money. The comments may be removed, filtered or hidden by the platform, and you will have no recourse because you were buying something the platform does not allow.
- Damage to trust. Viewers read comments to decide whether a video is worth their time. Generic, repetitive or off-topic comments make a channel look fake, and potential customers may assume your business is as well.
- Bad data. Comments are one of the simplest signals of what your audience wants. If a third are paid-for, you can no longer learn from them.
- Security and privacy. Many sellers ask for your channel link, an email address or payment details. You are handing information to a business that is already operating against the platform’s rules.
- Sponsor and partner checks. Brands and agencies often look at engagement quality when choosing who to work with. Odd comment patterns can end a conversation before it starts.
If you are weighing up the wider picture, our article on buying YouTube watch hours covers the same kind of trade-off for another metric, and the logic is identical: the number goes up, but nothing about your channel actually improves.
How fake engagement gets noticed
People often ask how anyone could tell. There are two groups who might notice: viewers and the platform.
Viewers notice by reading. A comment section where fifteen people say variations of “nice video, keep it up” within the same hour, with none of them mentioning anything in the video, reads as odd. Replies from the creator to those comments feel stilted too, because there is nothing real to reply to. If you have ever scrolled a comment section and thought “these are not real”, you have done the same check yourself. We cover that skill in more detail in our guide to spotting fake followers, and most of the same signs apply to comments: empty profiles, generic text, odd timing and no link to the content.
The platform notices by pattern. We cannot see inside YouTube’s systems, and nobody outside the company can say exactly which signals it uses, so we will not pretend to. What we can say, from the policy itself, is that YouTube states it does not count artificial traffic and will remove violating content. That is enough to know the risk is real.
The “it is only a few comments” argument
Some people reason that a handful of paid comments will just get a video started. The trouble with this approach is that it does not break the cycle, it feeds it. You then want the next video to look as busy as the last one, so you buy again, and the real engagement you might have earned never gets the chance to grow.
Why your comments might be low in the first place
Before you decide to buy youtube comments, it is worth asking why people are not commenting. In our experience it is rarely because the video is bad. It is usually one of these.
- Nobody asked. Most viewers will not comment unless you give them a reason. A closing line like “which of these would you try first?” turns a passive viewer into a participant.
- The video was not seen by enough people. A video with a few dozen views will only ever get a few comments. Comments follow views. Fix reach first.
- Comments are switched off or held. Check your settings in YouTube Studio. Strict moderation can hold many perfectly good comments, and you might not realise they are waiting for you.
- The topic does not invite discussion. A how-to video may get thanks; a debate, comparison or opinion gets responses.
- You are not replying. If past commenters never hear back, others learn there is no point in joining in.
Each of these can be fixed without spending anything on fake engagement.
Honest ways to get real YouTube comments
None of what follows is a trick. It is simply what tends to work for the small businesses and creators we speak to.
Ask a specific question
“Let me know what you think” is vague. “Have you used this method, and what happened?” gives people something to answer. Ask the question in the video itself, out loud, and repeat it in the pinned comment or description.
Reply to every comment, early
Replying quickly, especially in the first day after uploading, signals that you are listening. It also tends to produce follow-up comments, because people come back to see your answer. If you want to keep a conversation going, ask a question back.
Use the pinned comment properly
Pin a comment of your own that sets the tone: a question, a link to a related video, or a prompt such as “share your own example below”. It helps a new viewer see what kind of conversation is welcome.
Build a reason to talk into the video
Videos that include a choice, a challenge or a mild disagreement draw responses. For example, a comparison video that ends with “which would you pick?” will usually beat a plain tutorial for comments. A story from your own experience helps too, because people often reply with theirs.
Bring your existing audience over
If you already have a following elsewhere, such as email subscribers, an Instagram audience or customers in a shop, tell them about the video and invite their view. Real people who already know you are the easiest first commenters. Our article on how to get more Instagram comments covers prompts and habits that carry over well to YouTube.
Keep comment settings sensible
Go into YouTube Studio and look at your comment moderation level. If it is too strict, genuine comments may be sitting in the held tab waiting for approval. The help page says held comments are kept for a limited time and are not visible until you approve them, so it pays to check regularly.
Make videos worth discussing
This is the slowest answer and the best one. Strong titles and thumbnails bring in viewers, a good first thirty seconds keeps them, and a clear point of view gives them something to answer.
How long does it take to build a real comment section?
It depends on your topic and how often you publish, so we will not give you a number that sounds precise but is not. What we see is that channels who ask questions, reply consistently and publish regularly tend to see replies build gradually over weeks and months, rather than overnight. If your videos have very few views, expect few comments, and focus on getting the videos in front of the right people first.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to pay for comments on YouTube?
We are not lawyers and this is not legal advice. As far as we are aware, it is not a criminal matter in itself, but it does break YouTube’s rules, and misleading consumers with fake engagement can raise separate consumer protection questions for businesses. If you are unsure, take advice from a qualified professional.
Will YouTube ban my channel for buying comments?
If you buy youtube comments, YouTube’s policy says the content is removed and that a first violation usually leads to a warning. Repeat or severe violations can lead to strikes and termination. We cannot predict what would happen to a specific channel, but the risk is real and the benefit is not.
Do comments help a video rank?
We have not seen YouTube publish a clear statement that comment counts alone lift rankings, so we would not promise it. What comments do offer is a sign that viewers are interested, which feeds back into how you plan content. Genuine viewing and satisfaction are the better things to aim for.
What if someone else posted fake comments on my video?
You can remove them in YouTube Studio, report them, hide the user from your channel, or add blocked words and tighten moderation.
Can I ask friends and family to comment?
Asking people you know to watch and share a real opinion is normal. The line is paying for engagement, or asking people to post things they do not mean. A friend who watched and said something honest is fine; a script is not.
How many comments should a video have?
There is no standard figure. It depends on views, topic and audience.
Need a hand with your YouTube channel?
If you want real engagement for your channel, the honest route is slower than paying for it, but it lasts. Searching for buy youtube comments usually means you want a busier, more convincing channel, and we can help you build one with genuine content, a clear video plan and a community that actually speaks up. Have a look at Delivered Social to see how we work, or contact us for a friendly, no-pressure chat about your videos.
Loading article…
Keep reading
More on this.
Rather we just did it for you?
Let's get your business seen.
Social media, websites, SEO and ads from a team you can actually meet.
If you have uploaded a few videos and the comment section is empty, it is tempting to look at a shortcut. Searches for buy youtube comments are common for exactly that reason: an empty box under a video feels like a sign that nobody cares, and a busy one feels like proof that people do. This guide explains what actually happens when you pay for comments, what YouTube’s own rules say, where the real risks sit, and how to get genuine comments from real viewers instead.
We are a UK social media, SEO and web agency, based in Guildford and Portsmouth, and we help small businesses and creators with video every week. We will not tell you where to buy anything, because we do not think it is a good idea. What we can do is tell you plainly what you would be buying and what to do instead.
What happens when you buy youtube comments
Sellers usually offer a package: pay a set price and comments appear under your video within hours or days. They tend to fall into three types. The first is generic comments such as “great video” or “love this”, often posted from accounts with no history. The second is comments written from a list you supply or a seller’s script. The third is comments posted by real people paid a tiny amount per task, sometimes from other countries and with no interest in your topic.
All three share the same problem: none of those people watched your video because they wanted to. The comment is a decoration, not a conversation. Real comments ask questions, disagree, add a story, or mention a specific moment. Bought ones almost never do, and that difference is easy to spot for viewers and for YouTube’s systems.
There is also a practical issue. Comments from brand-new or empty accounts, posted in a burst, with similar wording, look exactly like spam. YouTube has comment filters designed to catch this kind of pattern, and creators can choose to hold comments for review. YouTube’s help page on holding comments explains that comments that may be spam, self-promotion or gibberish can be held and are not public unless approved. A comment you paid for can therefore disappear before anyone sees it.
What you get for your money
In plain terms, you get text under a video. You do not get an audience, watch time, subscribers or customers. The video’s performance still depends on whether people click it, stay watching and come back. A comment count with no matching views, likes or watch time looks odd, and that mismatch is one of the first things a careful viewer notices.
What YouTube’s rules say
This is the part that matters most. YouTube has a fake engagement policy. According to YouTube’s fake engagement policy, it does not allow anything that artificially increases the number of views, likes, comments or other metrics. The same page lists related behaviour that is also not allowed, including promoting services that inflate metrics and “sub4sub” arrangements where channels only subscribe to each other in return.
The page also describes what can happen. Content that breaks the policy is removed and you receive an email. For a first violation, YouTube says you will usually get a warning with no penalty to the channel. Repeating the same violation within the warning period can lead to a strike, and three strikes within 90 days can lead to the channel being terminated. Channels can also be terminated for repeated violations, for a single case of severe abuse, or if the channel exists mainly to break the rules. The policy also says that if you hire someone to promote your channel and they break the rules, that can lead to your channel being removed too.
We have summarised the policy as we read it on the day we wrote this. Policies change, so check the page itself before you decide anything.
Why a warning is not harmless
A first warning with no channel penalty sounds mild. But a warning is a record that your channel has been flagged. If you are a business building a video library, or a creator working toward monetisation, you do not want any history of rule-breaking attached to the channel you are trying to grow.
The real risks, beyond the rulebook
Even if you set YouTube’s policy aside, there are good commercial reasons not to buy youtube comments. Let us go through them one by one.
If you are weighing up the wider picture, our article on buying YouTube watch hours covers the same kind of trade-off for another metric, and the logic is identical: the number goes up, but nothing about your channel actually improves.
How fake engagement gets noticed
People often ask how anyone could tell. There are two groups who might notice: viewers and the platform.
Viewers notice by reading. A comment section where fifteen people say variations of “nice video, keep it up” within the same hour, with none of them mentioning anything in the video, reads as odd. Replies from the creator to those comments feel stilted too, because there is nothing real to reply to. If you have ever scrolled a comment section and thought “these are not real”, you have done the same check yourself. We cover that skill in more detail in our guide to spotting fake followers, and most of the same signs apply to comments: empty profiles, generic text, odd timing and no link to the content.
The platform notices by pattern. We cannot see inside YouTube’s systems, and nobody outside the company can say exactly which signals it uses, so we will not pretend to. What we can say, from the policy itself, is that YouTube states it does not count artificial traffic and will remove violating content. That is enough to know the risk is real.
The “it is only a few comments” argument
Some people reason that a handful of paid comments will just get a video started. The trouble with this approach is that it does not break the cycle, it feeds it. You then want the next video to look as busy as the last one, so you buy again, and the real engagement you might have earned never gets the chance to grow.
Why your comments might be low in the first place
Before you decide to buy youtube comments, it is worth asking why people are not commenting. In our experience it is rarely because the video is bad. It is usually one of these.
Each of these can be fixed without spending anything on fake engagement.
Honest ways to get real YouTube comments
None of what follows is a trick. It is simply what tends to work for the small businesses and creators we speak to.
Ask a specific question
“Let me know what you think” is vague. “Have you used this method, and what happened?” gives people something to answer. Ask the question in the video itself, out loud, and repeat it in the pinned comment or description.
Reply to every comment, early
Replying quickly, especially in the first day after uploading, signals that you are listening. It also tends to produce follow-up comments, because people come back to see your answer. If you want to keep a conversation going, ask a question back.
Use the pinned comment properly
Pin a comment of your own that sets the tone: a question, a link to a related video, or a prompt such as “share your own example below”. It helps a new viewer see what kind of conversation is welcome.
Build a reason to talk into the video
Videos that include a choice, a challenge or a mild disagreement draw responses. For example, a comparison video that ends with “which would you pick?” will usually beat a plain tutorial for comments. A story from your own experience helps too, because people often reply with theirs.
Bring your existing audience over
If you already have a following elsewhere, such as email subscribers, an Instagram audience or customers in a shop, tell them about the video and invite their view. Real people who already know you are the easiest first commenters. Our article on how to get more Instagram comments covers prompts and habits that carry over well to YouTube.
Keep comment settings sensible
Go into YouTube Studio and look at your comment moderation level. If it is too strict, genuine comments may be sitting in the held tab waiting for approval. The help page says held comments are kept for a limited time and are not visible until you approve them, so it pays to check regularly.
Make videos worth discussing
This is the slowest answer and the best one. Strong titles and thumbnails bring in viewers, a good first thirty seconds keeps them, and a clear point of view gives them something to answer.
How long does it take to build a real comment section?
It depends on your topic and how often you publish, so we will not give you a number that sounds precise but is not. What we see is that channels who ask questions, reply consistently and publish regularly tend to see replies build gradually over weeks and months, rather than overnight. If your videos have very few views, expect few comments, and focus on getting the videos in front of the right people first.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to pay for comments on YouTube?
We are not lawyers and this is not legal advice. As far as we are aware, it is not a criminal matter in itself, but it does break YouTube’s rules, and misleading consumers with fake engagement can raise separate consumer protection questions for businesses. If you are unsure, take advice from a qualified professional.
Will YouTube ban my channel for buying comments?
If you buy youtube comments, YouTube’s policy says the content is removed and that a first violation usually leads to a warning. Repeat or severe violations can lead to strikes and termination. We cannot predict what would happen to a specific channel, but the risk is real and the benefit is not.
Do comments help a video rank?
We have not seen YouTube publish a clear statement that comment counts alone lift rankings, so we would not promise it. What comments do offer is a sign that viewers are interested, which feeds back into how you plan content. Genuine viewing and satisfaction are the better things to aim for.
What if someone else posted fake comments on my video?
You can remove them in YouTube Studio, report them, hide the user from your channel, or add blocked words and tighten moderation.
Can I ask friends and family to comment?
Asking people you know to watch and share a real opinion is normal. The line is paying for engagement, or asking people to post things they do not mean. A friend who watched and said something honest is fine; a script is not.
How many comments should a video have?
There is no standard figure. It depends on views, topic and audience.
Need a hand with your YouTube channel?
If you want real engagement for your channel, the honest route is slower than paying for it, but it lasts. Searching for buy youtube comments usually means you want a busier, more convincing channel, and we can help you build one with genuine content, a clear video plan and a community that actually speaks up. Have a look at Delivered Social to see how we work, or contact us for a friendly, no-pressure chat about your videos.